Over to you Carl.......

Is it true that he's been offered a better deal than the one he was on last season?

I feel like I read that somewhere - not sure whether it came from the horse's mouth or someone's keyboard on here.

I'm guessing the problem is that any extra money he gets this season will go on travelling, which didn't used to cost so much last season when he car shared.

Is that basically the crux of it?

The guy knows he is loved here. And he's not just a right back - he's a cult hero now (whether you agree with that or not). And you can play him at left back and he'll put in just as good a performance as he would if he was at right back.

That's worth quite a lot at this level. I also believe he feels his strongest position is centre back!

He does, and he himself said he'd been offered a better deal than last season in the interview.

Good player, seems like a decent lad but right back s do not win leagues goal scorers do...........Maybe JF and PF have ring fenced a bit more budget for a better striker to come in?

So he gets paid a bit more and he aint happy yet Gowling takes a pay cut.  I like Magnay says it how it is and a consistent performer but im not sure what he is trying to achieve here.

There are plenty of RB's out there i hope we can get one in the mould of Lee Vaughan if he's still available or the lad that came on loan from Man City Logan or someone or someone of equivalent mould.

Vaughan has signed for someone I think and Shaleum Logan is playing in Scotland - possibly in Europe next season too.

Sure Hurst can use his computer to get cheap train tickets for him

Just listened to the interview on Radio Humberside and to me it sounds like a plea to improve the contract and if offered and he'd sign.
He states that he took a contract with us last year on the lowest paid senior pro, because he wanted to sign for Grimsby!  He was pretty much the last player to sign so nearly all the wage budget was gone and only the youth players earned less than him.
He has been offered improved wages (hope its not 50 quid extra a week or something embarrassing like that), he has also lost luxuries like car sharing with Hannah, Paddy and Parslow which may have made it a little more worth while.
He's not daft, players talk and they'll all know roughly what each other earns. He's gonna look at the higher paid players and think Christ that's what I want and yet I won all the Player of the Year awards, I've got a family to look out for and interest from Football League clubs.
We need to improve our offer to further reward what he's given the club and fans.
He wants to stay!!!!!  He's already stated that the offers from football league clubs, despite being better than what we've offered the clubs are smaller than us.
This guy has the passion we need to get us out of this god forsaken league, he has the ability to easily play in league two and above and he loves this club and us fans.

Come on Fenty and Hurst, do the right thing, improve the offer, we don't need to break the bank to do it. Just show Carl we need him and are serious about promotion before he leaves for a smaller club and regrets it later.

If we are too stretched maybe this message can go out to the Mullens too or maybe the town fans can raise some cash to cover costs.

utm

Quoted from Stew0_0

Just listened to the interview on Radio Humberside and to me it sounds like a plea to improve the contract and if offered and he'd sign.
He states that he took a contract with us last year on the lowest paid senior pro, because he wanted to sign for Grimsby!  He was pretty much the last player to sign so nearly all the wage budget was gone and only the youth players earned less than him.
He has been offered improved wages (hope its not 50 quid extra a week or something embarrassing like that), he has also lost luxuries like car sharing with Hannah, Paddy and Parslow which may have made it a little more worth while.
He's not daft, players talk and they'll all know roughly what each other earns. He's gonna look at the higher paid players and think Christ that's what I want and yet I won all the Player of the Year awards, I've got a family to look out for and interest from Football League clubs.
We need to improve our offer to further reward what he's given the club and fans.
He wants to stay!!!!!  He's already stated that the offers from football league clubs, despite being better than what we've offered the clubs are smaller than us.
This guy has the passion we need to get us out of this god forsaken league, he has the ability to easily play in league two and above and he loves this club and us fans.

Come on Fenty and Hurst, do the right thing, improve the offer, we don't need to break the bank to do it. Just show Carl we need him and are serious about promotion before he leaves for a smaller club and regrets it later.

If we are too stretched maybe this message can go out to the Mullens too or maybe the town fans can raise some cash to cover costs.

utm

Agree with all of the above till the Mullens bit. I'm really uncomfortable when we put the begging bowl out to a couple of fans who've had some good fortune. Let's not let the parlous state of the club's finances be an excuse to do this.

Quoted from HertsGTFC

Good player, seems like a decent lad but right back s do not win leagues goal scorers do...........

Defences win points though. Keep a clean sheet and you have got 1 point, then the strikers can turn it into 3 !

The mullens have been more than generous so far, it isn't up to them to finance the club.
I've said it before- we only have a finite amount of money- we cannot blow it all on Magnay.
I'm of the opinion that if he has been offered what he is worth and what we can afford and it isn't enough then so be it- let him go. His bitching about it before anything is signed or official had knocked him down a few pegs in my estimation.